NEW DELHI:
The Supreme Court on Thursday said that recruitment rules cannot be amended midway after the selection process has commenced, unless provided otherwise in the extant rules or the recruitment advertisement.
A Constitution Bench, headed by CJI, DY Chandrachud, said that an appointing authority, in absence of rules to the contrary, can devise a procedure for selection of a candidate suitable to the post and may set different benchmarks for different stages of the recruitment process.
“However, if any such benchmark is set, the same should be set before the commencement of the recruitment process. But, if the rules empower the competent authority to set benchmarks at different stages of the recruitment process, then such benchmarks may be set before that stage is reached so that neither candidates nor invigilators are taken by surprise,” ruled the five-judge Constitution Bench.
The Bench, also comprising Justices Hrishikesh Roy, PS Narasimha, Pankaj Mithal and Manoj Misra, said that if change in eligibility criteria is permitted under rules or advertisement, the change will have to satisfy the test of non-arbitrariness.
It said, “The object of any process of selection for entry into public service is to ensure that a person suitable for the post is selected. What is suitable for one post cannot be for another. Thus, a degree of discretion is necessary to be left to the employer to devise a method to select a candidate most suitable for the post.”
In its judgment, the top court stressed the recruiting bodies, subject to the extant rules, may devise appropriate procedure for bringing the recruitment process to its logical end, provided that the procedure adopted is transparent, non-discriminatory, non-arbitrary and has a rational nexus to the objects sought to be achieved.
The Constitution Bench was hearing a reference after a three-judge Bench doubted the correctness of an earlier decision, where it was held that the selection criteria cannot be changed midway during the recruitment process.
more recommended stories
Protesting Punjab Farmers Try to Break Barricades, Face Teargas Shells at Shambhu BorderCHANDIGARH:Security forces on Friday used teargas.
Israel Threatens to Escalate Attacks if Truce with Hezbollah CollapsesJERUSALEM:Israel has warned that it would.
SC Orders Jacobite Church to Hand Over Six Churches to the Orthodox ChurchNEW DELHI:The Supreme Court on Tuesday.
Cyclone Fengal: Chennai Airport Temporarily Halts OperationsCHENNAI:The Chennai International Airport has temporarily.
Trump Names Kolkata-born Doctor-researcher to Head Health Research PowerhouseNEW YORK:US President-Elect Donald Trump has.
Kannur ADM Suicide: Kerala HC Accepts Wife’s Plea Seeking CBI ProbeKOCHI:The Kerala High Court on Wednesday.
Photo of Cops Violating Sabarimala Temple Traditions Goes Viral; Report SoughtPATHANAMTHITTA:A picture of Kerala policemen in.
Priyanka Gandhi Wins Debut Election from Wayanad by a Margin of Over 4 LakhKALPETTA:Right from the day the Congress.
India Under Trump 2.0 Could Bolster its Position in Global Supply ChainsNEW DELHI:As Donald Trump returns as.
Priyanka Gandhi Consolidates Massive Lead in Wayanad Lok Sabha BypollKALPETTA:Congress General Secretary Priyanka Gandhi Vadra,.